Just weeks after launching a campaign to allow insurance companies to adjust automobile premiums based on coverage history, backers of a ballot measure are rebooting their efforts in a bad to stave off critics.
Californians for Fair Auto Insurance Rates, underwritten by Mercury General, has submitted new referendum language it says more clearly narrows the proposed referendum's scope. While amounting to less than two sentences, the changes required new draft language to be submitted to the state Attorney General's office for approval.
The new draft removes the sentence, "When calculating the discount or determining the eligibility for a continuity discount an insurer may also take into account the applicant's or insured's claims experience." Critics, including the advocacy group Consumer Watchdog, claimed that phrasing was a back-door means of punishing policyholders who file claims, or filed claims in the past, even when they were not at fault (BestWire, Aug. 18, 2009).
Consumer Watchdog has also objected to the larger issue of the initiative, saying it will penalize consumers who had decided not to drive and let their insurance lapse, as well as those who filed a late payment.
"There seemed to be some confusion about language in our original measure that was being misinterpreted to do more than simply make the continuous coverage discount portable. Specifically, the Attorney General questioned whether a provision would allow the absence of prior insurance coverage to more generally be a factor in determining rates," Jim Conran, co-chairman of Californians for Fair Auto Insurance Rates and president of Consumers First, an independent insurance agency network, said in a statement
The Continuous Coverage Auto Insurance Discount Act would allow insurance companies to lower premiums for drivers who "have continuously maintained auto insurance coverage," even if they switch to a different insurer. The initiative would correct an inconsistency in state law that discourages consumers from switching to another insurance company, CalFAIR spokeswoman Kathy Fairbanks said.
CalFAIR had begun to gather signatures to put the initiative on the June 2010 primary election ballot, but had to abandon that effort, Fairbanks said. Once the Attorney General's office approves the language, the drive to gather the 433,971 valid signatures can begin again. CalFAIR is now working toward appearing on the ballot "sometime in 2010," Fairbanks said.
CalFAIR's campaign is underwritten by Mercury General Corp., the state's third-largest writer of automobile insurance policies, which to date has been the campaign's sole donor. The insurer and its affiliates have donated $500,000 to the campaign, plus $12,000 in "non-monetary" support, according to California campaign finance records. The campaign Web site includes the disclaimer, "Paid for by Californians for Fair Auto Insurance Rates and Mercury General Corporation and Affiliates."
Mercury Insurance Co., a member of Mercury General Group, currently has a Best's Financial Strength Rating of A+ (Superior).
The top five writers of private passenger auto insurance in California in 2008, based on A.M. Best Co. state/line data, were: State Farm Group, with a 12.9% market share; Farmers Insurance Group, 11.0%; Mercury General Group, 9.4%; Auto Club Enterprises Insurance Group, 9.0%; and Allstate Insurance Group, 8.4%.
-
Farmers Acquires 21st Century Insurance
Apr. 17--American International Group bailed out of the auto insurance business on Thursday, selling Woodland... -
Meet Justin Case (Though He Doesn't Really Exist): More Advertisers Are Choosing "Average Joe"
Justin Case has a cubicle on the fourth floor of SafeAuto's headquarters building in Columbus. On his... -
Appeal Court Upholds Alberta's $4,000 Cap on Payouts for Min
EDMONTON - Alberta's $4,000 cap on insurance payouts for whiplash injuries was revived Friday by an Appeal... -
Hit By an Uninsured Motorist? Get Help With Auto Insurance Claim Questions
SOLON, Ohio, June 24 /PRNewswire/ -- Nationally, almost 15% of drivers don't have auto insurance -- and... -
Holywood's Rory McIlroy Has Forked Out for a New Ferrari F430 in Gun-Metal Grey
RORY McIlroy is facing a five-figure annual sum for his car insurance alone after becoming the proud owner... -
Progressive's MyRate Plan Pegs Customers' Driving Style To R
Jun. 17--Drivers who keep their lead foot off the gas and quit jamming on the brakes could steer their...
Today's Top Picks
- HOT
- Latest
- Last Post
- Rand
- how much is car insurance for a 16 year
- Farmers Acquires 21st Century Insurance
- an insurance policy with bodily
- Meet Justin Case (Though He Doesn't Really
- Cheap Car Insurance for Young Drivers -
- Appeal Court Upholds Alberta's $4,000 Cap
- Hit By an Uninsured Motorist? Get Help With
- Holywood's Rory McIlroy Has Forked Out for
- Progressive's MyRate Plan Pegs Customers'
- Progressive Raising Rates ; Other Mass.
- Lack of Driver's License, No Bar to Getting
- Top Erie Insurance earns JD Power and Associates
- Insurance.Com's RateWatch Finds Average
- Can Gap insurance beat falling car values?
- First Mobile Auto Claims Reporting App for
- J.D. Power Survey Ranks The Hartford High
- Comparethemarket.Com
- AIG to Sell 21st Century Insurance to FGI
- Has Your Owner's Wrap-Up Insurance Got You
- Age law 'will drive up car insurance costs'
-
Holywood's Rory McIlroy Has Forked Out for a New Ferrari F430 in Gun-Metal Grey
RORY McIlroy is facing a five-figure annual sum for his car insurance alone after becoming the proud owner... -
Progressive's MyRate Plan Pegs Customers' Driving Style To R
Jun. 17--Drivers who keep their lead foot off the gas and quit jamming on the brakes could steer their... -
Progressive Raising Rates ; Other Mass. Auto Insurers Angry
Boston Herald Published: Saturday, March 28, 2009 By JAY FITZGERALD Known for its super-cheap auto insurance... -
Lack of Driver's License, No Bar to Getting Insurance
No driver's license, no car insurance, right? Wrong. Auto insurance companies have realized what other... -
Top Erie Insurance earns JD Power and Associates customer satisfaction Prix two years in a row
ERIE, Pennsylvania, June 23 / PRNewswire / - Erie Insurance has earned JD Power and Associates to the... -
Insurance.Com's RateWatch Finds Average Teen Auto Insurance
While average auto insurance rates across the United States continue tocome down from their record highs...
Featured Stories
-
how much is car insurance for a 16 year old
-
Farmers Acquires 21st Century Insurance
-
Cheap Car Insurance for Young Drivers - Useful Strategies
-
Appeal Court Upholds Alberta's $4,000 Cap on Payouts for Min
-
Holywood's Rory McIlroy Has Forked Out for a New Ferrari F430 in Gun-Metal Grey
-
Top Erie Insurance earns JD Power and Associates customer satisfaction Prix two years in a row
Insurance News Health Insurance Life Insurance Property Insurance Casualty Insurance Car Insurance Travel Insurance Reinsurance News Breaking News Law&Regulation insurance videos insurance jobs
Contact Us | Privacy Policy | Sitemap | Rssmap
Use of this website signifies your agreement to the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy insurancenewsnet.org All rights reserved.