Budget Umpire: Health Care Bills Would Raise Costs
Saturday, Jul 18,2009, 10:53:12 AM Click:
The sobering assessment from Congressional Budget Office Director Douglas Elmendorf came as House Democrats pushed to pass a partisan bill through committees, while in the Senate a small group of lawmakers continued to seek a deal that could win support from both political parties.
The United States is the only developed nation that does not have a comprehensive national health care plan for all its citizens, and Obama campaigned on a promise to offer affordable health care to all Americans.
About 50 million of America's 300 million people are without health insurance. The government provides coverage for the poor and elderly, but most Americans rely on private insurance, usually received through their employers. However, not all employers provide insurance and not everyone can afford to buy it on their own. With unemployment rising, many Americans are losing their health insurance when they lose their jobs.
However, the recession and a deepening budget deficit have made it difficult to win support for costly new programs. Obama says that overhauling health care is vital to the United States' long-term economic recovery.
Senators involved in the bipartisan talks said Thursday evening they are making solid progress toward a compromise they claimed would hold down costs, addressing the budgetary concerns. But it could take more time to work out difficult issues. And that means that Obama's timetable for floor votes in the House and Senate before August would slip.
"I think it would be prudent of the president to be patient and allow us the opportunity to work," said Republican Sen. Olympia Snowe, one of the lawmakers involved in talks led by Finance Committee Chairman Max Baucus, a Democrat like Obama.
"I don't think we should be bound by a timetable that isn't realistic," said Snowe, adding that a Senate vote in September would still allow time to finish the legislation this fall.
Baucus said he's "quite confident" that the group is "making a lot of progress" and would be ready fairly soon.
From the beginning of the health care debate, Obama has insisted that any overhaul must "bend the curve" of rapidly rising costs that threaten to swamp the budgets of government, businesses and families.
Asked by Senate Budget Committee Chairman Kent Conrad if the evolving legislation would bend the cost curve, the budget director responded that _ as things stand now _ "the curve is being raised."
Explained Elmendorf: "In the legislation that has been reported, we do not see the sort of fundamental changes that would be necessary to reduce the trajectory of federal health spending by a significant amount. And on the contrary, the legislation significantly expands the federal responsibility for health care costs."
Even if the legislation doesn't add to the federal deficit over the next years, Elmendorf said costs over the long run would keep rising at an unsustainable pace.
Part of the reason is that Obama and most Democrats have refused to accept a tax on high-cost health insurance plans as part of the overhaul. There's wide agreement among economists that such a tax would give businesses and individuals an incentive to become thriftier consumers of health care. Finance Chairman Baucus said Thursday that Obama's position isn't helping matters.
White House officials played down the significance of the budget director's assessment, calling it premature. "At the end of the day, we'll have significant cost controls," presidential adviser David Axelrod told The Associated Press.
Senate Republican leader Mitch McConnell said the budget director's warning should be "a wake-up call," adding, "instead of rushing through one expensive proposal after another, we should take the time we need to get things right."
For the fourth straight day, Obama used a public forum _ a political rally for New Jersey Gov. Jon Corzine _ to argue for health care overhaul, saying, "It affects the stability of our entire economy."
Despite the flashing yellow light from the budget office, the House pushed ahead.
On the heels of the Senate health committee's approval Wednesday of a plan to provide coverage to the uninsured, three House committees shifted into action on their version of the legislation. Early Friday, the House Ways and Means Committee voted 23 to 18 to send the revenue portions of the bill to the House floor.
The bill seeks to provide coverage to nearly all Americans by subsidizing the poor and penalizing individuals and employers who don't purchase health insurance. It would boost taxes on high-income people and slow Medicare and Medicaid payments to providers.
The Democratic bills also call for the creation of a government-sponsored insurance plan to compete with private coverage, although they differ on the details.
House Democrats won a coveted endorsement of their legislation from the American Medical Association, saying the bill "includes a broad range of provisions that are key to effective, comprehensive health system reform. The insurance industry said it opposes key elements of the bill, saying a government plan "will cause millions of patients to lose their current coverage."
___
Associated Press writers Erica Werner, Charles Babington, Stephen Ohlemacher, Philip Elliott and Alan Fram contributed to this report.
You may also be interested in:
Featured
MaybachFinancial.com Posts Free Analyst Report on ETN,
LONDON -- (MARKET WIRE) -- 04/23/09 -- MaybachFinancial.com is one of the
Insurers Go Green and Turn Off Paper Statements
My colleague, Emmett Higdon, wrote an article recently on how banks can
Mass. Gov. Wants to Expand Power of Regulators to
Massachusetts Gov. Deval Patrick has proposed reforms that include expanding
Insurance Groups Urge Slowing Down Health Reform
WASHINGTON, April 22, 2009 The Independent Insurance Agents Brokers of America
About NAIC Insurers pursuit of its own rating agency
Copyright: A.M. Best Company, Inc. Source: BestWire Services Wordcount: Some
CORRECTING and REPLACING NaviNet Announces NaviNet
SAN DIEGO--(BUSINESS WIRE)-- Second graph, quote should be attributed to: Ed
FDIC Approves the Payout of Insured Deposits of
FDIC Approves the Payout of Insured Deposits of Platinum Community Bank,
MOST POPULAR
- Most Read
- Most Discussed
- Most Emailed
- average monthly cost for health insurance
- Aetna CEO Ronald A. Williams' 2008 Pay Package: $3.14 Millio
- House Democrats Say CBO Projects $500 Billion in Gross Savings From Medicare
- UnitedHealth, Aetna Win TRICARE contracts, Replacement Humana, Health Net
- Getting Older, but working longer: the average age at retire
- Tap Retirement Funds Penalty-Free Age Can Play A Role IRA
- Extension of TRICARE Health Insurance Coverage Included
- "Usual and Customary" Rates in the Health Insurance Industry
- Health Plans awaiting verdict in 2010 Medicare Advantage Cut
- President Obama to Hold Health Insurance Reform Rally in College Park, MD
-
Getting Older, but working longer: the average age at retire -
New Report Details How to create an option for public health -
Towers Perrin Experts available to discuss factors influenci -
Rx for health care -
Beware of Sharks annuity -
Stephen L. Blake, AIG's Head of Human Resources, to testify -
Health Insurers Profits Sink -
High-Deductible Health Plans Often Enroll Low-Income Vulnera


Discuss this news
Click Here to see all comments